Struggling to find you in the crowd

Eyes are screaming, your words don’t make a sound

You looked better in your Goodwill clothes

No one’s gonna recognize you now

You’ll always be my last year’s valentine

Last year’s valentine

Yea that was me across the street

With a box of chocolate I know you won’t eat

Why am I holding this over-stuffed bear?

That I bought at last month’s swap meet

You’ll always be my last year’s valentine

Last year’s valentine

You’ll always be my last year’s valentine

Last year’s valentine

Ooo (aah)

Ooo (aah)

Ooo (aah)

Ooo (aah)

Halloween is where it all went wrong

Saw you making out with my cousin Ron

I get it he’s an all American

At least that’s where I met your sister Dawn

She became my next year’s valentine

Next year’s valentine

She became my next year’s valentine

Next year’s valentine